Shame Doesn't Pay the Bills
I came across a phrase recently that I haven’t been able to stop thinking about:
Shame doesn’t pay the bills.
I don’t remember where I first heard it, and I’m not sure it hit me immediately.
But the more I thought about it, the bigger the phrase became.
Because I don’t think the “bills” are just your mortgage, electricity, or the balance sitting on your credit card.
I think we all have other bills to pay.
The life you want to build.
The goals you keep telling yourself you’re going to pursue.
The business you want to start.
The gym you’re afraid to walk into.
The instrument you’ve always wanted to learn.
The thing you want to create.
The person you’re trying to become.
And one of the easiest ways to avoid paying those bills is to become overly concerned with what everybody else is going to think while you’re doing it.
Because what if you look stupid?
What if you fail?
What if somebody criticizes you?
What if you start a business and someone asks how many clients you have—and the answer is zero?
What if you walk into the gym overweight and have no idea how to use half the equipment?
What if you publish something and nobody reads it?
What if you record yourself speaking and hate the sound of your own voice?
Those feelings are real.
But there’s a question worth asking:
How much authority should they have over your life?
The Cost of Being Seen Trying
I think one of the hardest parts of starting something new as an adult is being willing to be seen before you’re good at it.
There’s a strange vulnerability in being a beginner.
You know where you want to go, but your current ability doesn’t match your ambition yet.
You’re not who you once were because you’ve decided you want something different.
But you’re not yet the person you’re trying to become.
You’re in between.
I’ve written before about this liminal space because I think it shows up everywhere in behavior change.
And it’s uncomfortable.
You might know you want to become a writer while simultaneously knowing your writing isn’t very good yet.
You might want to become a bodybuilder while looking nothing like one.
You might want to build a business while having no clients.
You might want to become a speaker while stumbling over your words.
There’s nothing wrong with that.
You don’t have to earn the right to begin by already being good at the thing you’re beginning.
I think we forget that.
We see the finished product of other people and compare it to our beginning.
Then social media makes the comparison even easier.
You see the successful business.
The polished speaker.
The person with the incredible physique.
The artist whose work looks effortless.
You usually don’t see the hundreds or thousands of repetitions that came before it.
And if your requirement for beginning is that nobody can ever see you struggle, fail, or look inexperienced, you’ve created an impossible standard.
You cannot become good at something while simultaneously requiring yourself to never look bad doing it.
You Have to Be Willing to Look Like a Beginner
I think about my first couple of years in the gym.
I didn't know everything I was doing.
I asked questions.
I tried things.
I got things wrong.
I changed things.
I kept showing up.
And thankfully, I wasn’t particularly concerned about whether asking somebody about an exercise made me look inexperienced.
Because I was inexperienced.
That was the entire point.
The only way I was going to become more knowledgeable was by being willing to admit that there were things I didn’t know.
The same thing has happened with My Disciplined Mind.
I put off pieces of this for a long time because I worried about perception.
Who is going to listen to me as a coach?
Who is going to read what I write?
What happens when somebody asks how business is?
What are people going to think when I start putting myself out there?
Even recording audio versions of these articles took me time.
I worried about my voice.
I worried that I would sound like I was reading a script.
And you know what?
Sometimes I probably do.
I'm learning.
But there’s only one way I’m going to get better at speaking.
I have to speak.
There was only one way I was going to become a better writer.
I had to write.
There was only one way I was going to become a better coach.
I had to coach.
Some of my early attempts weren't as good as what I can produce today.
Hopefully what I produce a year from now will make what I'm producing today look inexperienced too.
That would mean I kept growing.
Shame Is Information. It Isn't Instruction.
I want to be careful here.
This isn't an argument for never caring what anyone thinks.
And it certainly isn't an argument for ignoring criticism.
Some criticism is incredibly valuable.
If somebody has knowledge I don't have, experience I haven't earned yet, or can see something I'm missing, I want that information.
Everything is information.
But information isn't instruction.
There’s a difference.
Someone can give you feedback without getting control over the decision.
Someone can dislike what you're doing without automatically being right about what you should do next.
Someone can criticize your work and still give you something useful to think about.
So when criticism comes, I think there are better questions than simply asking whether it hurts.
Does this person understand what I'm trying to accomplish?
Do they have relevant knowledge or experience?
Are they pointing toward something specific that I can improve?
Are they criticizing the work, or are they simply assigning something negative to me as a person?
If my writing is unclear, tell me.
If my coaching has a weakness, I want to know.
If my training execution needs work, show me.
I can use that.
But “I think what you're doing is stupid” doesn't give me very much to work with.
Not every opinion deserves equal weight.
Your Spotlight Is Probably Brighter in Your Head
There’s actually a psychological phenomenon called the spotlight effect.
In experiments, people have tended to overestimate how much other people notice their appearance and behavior.
In other words, we sometimes walk through the world feeling like there's a spotlight on us that isn't nearly as bright to everyone else.
I find that incredibly freeing.
Not because nobody is going to judge you.
They might.
People have opinions.
You have opinions.
I have opinions.
That's part of being human.
But somebody thinking your idea is stupid for thirty seconds is very different from you allowing that thirty-second opinion to determine the next ten years of your life.
Someone might judge you when you walk into the gym.
They're not responsible for your health ten years from now.
Someone might think your business idea is ridiculous.
They're not responsible for the regret you'll experience if you never try.
Someone might think your first painting is terrible.
They don't have to live with the question of what your 500th painting might have looked like.
Other people's opinions are free. The consequences of listening to them aren't.
Accountability Doesn't Require Self-Destruction
There's another side to this that matters.
“Shame doesn't pay the bills” cannot become an excuse to avoid accountability.
Sometimes you do something poorly.
Sometimes you fail.
Sometimes the criticism is correct.
Sometimes you weren't prepared.
Sometimes you didn't work hard enough.
Sometimes your idea actually isn't very good.
Okay.
Now what?
You don't have to turn:
“That wasn't good enough.”
into:
“I'm not good enough.”
Those are completely different statements.
In fact, research on self-compassion suggests that treating yourself with less self-attack after failure doesn't necessarily make you complacent. In experimental research, self-compassion has actually been associated with greater motivation to improve after mistakes and weaknesses.
That makes sense to me.
Accountability and shame are not the same thing.
I can acknowledge that my first recording wasn't very good without deciding I shouldn't record anymore.
I can recognize that an article missed the mark without deciding I'm not a writer.
I can have a terrible workout without deciding I'm terrible at training.
The result is information.
Use it.
Adjust.
Keep going.
Get Over Yourself
If you were sitting across from me over coffee and told me:
“Adam, I really want to do this, but I'm worried people are going to think I'm ridiculous.”
I'd probably tell you:
Get over yourself.
And I mean that in the best way possible.
People are going to have opinions.
Some will be positive.
Some will be negative.
Some will be useful.
Some will be completely irrelevant.
You do the exact same thing.
The goal isn't to reach some enlightened place where you never care what another human being thinks about you again.
I don't think that's realistic.
The goal is to become better at deciding which opinions deserve weight.
Imagine having an opportunity to walk up to someone you deeply respect.
Maybe they're a world-class coach.
An incredible businessperson.
A speaker you've followed for years.
Someone who possesses knowledge that could fundamentally change the direction of what you're trying to build.
And you have a question you desperately want to ask them.
But you don't.
Because you're afraid you'll sound stupid.
You walk away.
They leave.
The opportunity is gone.
Which feeling lasts longer?
The few seconds of discomfort it would have taken to ask the question?
Or wondering what you might have learned if you'd been willing to feel uncomfortable?
That's what “shame doesn't pay the bills” means to me.
It doesn't mean the emotion isn't real.
It means the emotion doesn't automatically get the deciding vote.
What Might Your Shame Be Costing Someone Else?
There's another part of this I didn't fully appreciate until recently.
For a long time, I worried about whether anyone would care about what I wrote.
Then people started reaching out.
I've had someone tell me they were in a really dark place and something I wrote helped them.
And those moments changed the equation for me.
Because now I have to ask myself:
What if I hadn't written it?
What if worrying about whether somebody would judge my writing had been more powerful than my willingness to publish it?
What if I had decided I wasn't “ready”?
I don't say that because I think everything I create is profound.
Far from it.
I say it because sometimes what you're afraid to put into the world isn't only about you.
Maybe it's a business that eventually employs somebody.
Maybe it's music somebody needs to hear.
Maybe it's a painting that means something to one person.
Maybe it's a conversation you were afraid to start.
Maybe it's walking into the gym and changing the trajectory of your health.
You don't know.
And neither do the people whose judgment you're so afraid of.
Pay Your Own Bills
Social judgment is uncomfortable.
Research supports that too. Being negatively evaluated by other people can create a genuine stress response.
So I'm not going to tell you to pretend you don't care.
I care.
I'm simply learning to give that feeling less authority.
I'm getting more comfortable being uncomfortable.
And every time I publish another article, record another audio piece, make another video, coach another person, or walk into another situation where I don't have all the answers, I'm practicing.
Not practicing how to never feel shame.
Practicing how to move while feeling it.
Because there's a life I want to build.
There are things I want to create.
There are people I want to help.
There are skills I haven't mastered yet.
And I don't want fear of somebody else's opinion deciding how far I'm willing to go.
So feel the embarrassment.
Notice the judgment.
Listen to the criticism.
Take whatever information is useful.
Get curious about why it bothers you.
Then decide for yourself what happens next.
Because shame can make you hesitate.
It can make you hide.
It can convince you that being seen trying is somehow worse than never trying at all.
But shame doesn't have to live with the life you didn't build.
You do.
And shame doesn't pay the bills.
Keep Building.
Every week, I write about fitness, behavior change, discipline, and the systems that help us stop getting in our own way.
No hype. No generic motivation. Just practical ideas to help you better understand your behavior, make more intentional decisions, and keep building the person you know you're capable of becoming.
Join the My Disciplined Mind Newsletter →
Comments